Results
| Favourite | Kickoff | Fixture | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FT |
Nashville SC New York City FC |
2 1 |
L | |
| FT |
Columbus Crew New York City FC |
1 0 |
L | |
| FT |
New York Red Bulls New York City FC |
1 1 |
D | |
| FT |
Charlotte New York City FC |
0 1 |
W | |
| FT |
New York City FC Columbus Crew |
3 0 |
W | |
| FT |
New York City FC DC United |
0 2 |
L | |
| FT |
New York Red Bulls New York City FC |
1 3 |
W | |
| FT |
CF Montreal New York City FC |
1 0 |
L | |
| FT |
New York City FC FC Cincinnati |
4 4 |
D | |
| FT |
New York City FC Charlotte |
1 2 |
L |
New York City FC